The alternate 1. Nd8 works and is confirmed. It is mate in four just like the given solution.
———
Chess: Advance of the rook — We continue our examination of chess games by the master of positional play Ulf Andersson. Here he has built up a dominating position, principally by controlling the only open file. But a breakthrough is still needed: over to Ronan. RB: Everything points to an immediate 1 Rd6 – White's doubled rooks on the d-file, the pawn on e5 and the difficult position of the black knight on c6. But it does involve an exchange sacrifice and I have what must qualify as a near-phobia about giving up rooks for minor pieces. Still, if ever there was a time to get over my fears this surely has to be it. After 1…Bxd6 White could recapture with the rook, 2 Rxd6 but this doesn't seem to ...
Posted by lighttotheright beck-web.com
5/05/2008 04:38:41 Play online chess |
Message: Heinzkat -- I'm not wrong. 1. Nd8 does work. The problem is that no computer can solve this particular problem from four moves out. The computer checking the solutions is wrong.
Once you input the solution, the computer suddenly sees the solution at 2 or 3 moves out depending upon the program that you use. This particular puzzle is an anti-computer one.
|
Posted by heinzkat beck-web.com
5/05/2008 04:47:30 Play online chess | Lighttotheright!
Message: This is the interesting part of the puzzle, which is not covered in puzzle #283, since the puzzle application didn't support underpromotions of the opposite side back then. After 1. Nd8? [if I may boldly give it a ?] c2
2. Qc1 b1=B! Black is stalemated and there can be no mate in four.
After 1. Nb4 however, 1. ... c2 2. Qc1 b1=B 3. Nd3! exd3 4. Qh1, it IS mate in four :-)
|
Posted by chessnovice beck-web.com
5/05/2008 04:48:12 Play online chess | ...
Message: Sometimes puzzle makers don't have solutions entered entirely. Human error is prone to omissions. If you find an alternate solution, you're able to enter it. Nothing to necessarily get irritated about, I think.
|
Posted by heinzkat beck-web.com
5/05/2008 04:55:26 Play online chess | Also...
Message: Remember GameKnot does no checking of the puzzle at all - the puzzle application merely checks if all variations end in checkmate. If so, the puzzle is 'approved' 'correct' (twice '', ah well) an can be put up for others to solve. As you can see on the puzzle page, a lot of the puzzles still have some hiatuses then. If you think 1. Nd8 mates in four too, 'prove it'! You can do so by browsing to puzzle #283, hover over 'Options' in the right corner and click 'Alt. solution...'. This will give you the option to prove there is another way to play, that results in mate in at most the same number of moves as the original author. If all variations are correct, you can save the puzzle too, and the puzzle has been 'improved'.
|
Posted by lighttotheright beck-web.com
5/05/2008 04:58:36 Play online chess |
Message: 1. Nd8 c2 2. Qc1 b1=B 3. Nd5 Qb2 (or any move) 4. Nc7#
It is forced checkmate. There is no stalemate with my solution. The alternate is confirmed, and not seen by computer at four moves out.
|
Posted by lighttotheright beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:00:17 Play online chess |
Message: 1. Nd8 c2 2. Qc1 b1=B 3. Nd5 Bb2 (or any move) 4. Nc7#
Sorry I made a slight error in copying the line. This is correct.
|
Posted by heinzkat beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:01:19 Play online chess | 2. ... b1=B!
Message: Not 2. ... b1=Q. Please re-evaluate your assessments. :-)
(note that I hadn't noticed the b1=B solution either. A nice brilliancy by Ado Kraemer)
|
Posted by heinzkat beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:02:30 Play online chess | Lighttotheright
Message: 3. ... Bb2 is not possible in the intended line! It's 2. ... b1=B, not 2. ... bxc1=B.
|
Posted by lighttotheright beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:03:18 Play online chess |
Message: I did it again.
1. Nd8 c2 2. Qc1 b1=B 3. Ne6 Bb2 (or any move) 4. Nc7#
Those knight moves can get confusing.
I think this is correct now.
|
Posted by lighttotheright beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:06:00 Play online chess |
Message: Heinskat look at the position. The key to the solutiion is the knight path. The Queen sac is to block any defence by black. The solution is very simple. 1. Nb4 and 1. Nd8 both work.
|
Posted by heinzkat beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:06:23 Play online chess | Note that in your line...
Message: 3. ... Bb2 is illegal. In fact, after 3. Ne6, all Black's moves are illegal - it is stalemate!
|
Posted by heinzkat beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:09:59 Play online chess | OK... with a diagram then...
Message: After
1. Nd8 c2
2. Qc1 b1=B
3. Ne6
It is Black to move. Do you see any legal ones?
Interesting how Ado Kraemer can still keep us busy with his brilliant problems, 36 years after he died.
|
Posted by lighttotheright beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:14:36 Play online chess |
Message: OK heinzkat. You threw me for a loop with b1. I was thinking about the c1 square. But even with b1=B, it is still checkmate in four. 1. Nd8 b1=b 2. Qxc3 and my solution still works.
|
Posted by heinzkat beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:21:11 Play online chess | Well...
Message: 1. Nd8 c2
2. Qc1 b1=B is the line that makes mate in four impossible.
1. Nd8 b1=B like you give in this last post, perfectly mates in four - but there's a difference. Carefully check the notations right from the beginning of this thread, I think I haven't messed up any of them...
|
Posted by lighttotheright beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:21:54 Play online chess |
Message: OK...It is still not stalemate. But it would be a mate in 5 instead. 1. Nd8 c2 2. Qc1 b1=B 3. Qxc2 and it is not stalemate. ...but it does take an extra turn to get the knight to c7.
|
Posted by lighttotheright beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:24:17 Play online chess |
Message: Sorry for some of the copy mistakes. My copy function on my computer is not working. I have to reboot my whole computer to correct the problem.
|
Posted by heinzkat beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:24:20 Play online chess | Exactly...
Message: And therefore, 1. Nd8 is an incorrect try. Mate in five is possible in many ways - there is only one correct starting move to mate in four.
|
Posted by lighttotheright beck-web.com
5/05/2008 05:58:50 Play online chess |
Message: Well, it looked correct to me at the time. And my computer was not cooperating with me either!
|
Posted by chessnovice beck-web.com
5/06/2008 13:55:37 Play online chess | ...
Message: b1=B is pretty clever! Indeed, prolongs the Nd8 line by one move. I wouldn't worry about not considering that though, since I doubt that very many people really would.
|
Posted by bogg beck-web.com
5/06/2008 15:13:15 Play online chess | In case anyone else has the ...
Message: same problem that I had. The reason that 2. ... b1=B doesn't cook 1.Nb4 and does cook 1. Nd4 and 1. Nd8 is because after 1.Nd4 White has 3. Nd3 ed: 4. Qh1++.
Took me a while to see the tree within the forest.
CTC
|
Posted by heinzkat beck-web.com
5/07/2008 01:30:09 Play online chess | chessnovice
Message: Obviously the composer did consider it :)
bogg: indeed, see my post above too, 5/05/2008 04:47:30
|
Posted by chessnovice beck-web.com
5/07/2008 01:44:28 Play online chess | hienzkat
Message: True. But if you can't trust the composer, who can you trust?
|
Posted by bogg beck-web.com
5/07/2008 06:35:06 Play online chess | heinzkat
Message: Missed that post. Would have saved me some time had I noticed it.
CTC
|